BUCS LATEST SCORELoading score…
NFL SCORES
Loading NFL scores…
INDEPENDENT VOICES. TAMPA BAY ROOTS.
FROM THE BAY.
BEYOND THE SCORE.
Other Sports / Analysis

The Rays’ Next World Series Problem Is the Innings After Their Starter

On Sunday, Oct. 25, the World Series is between games, but the Rays’ most urgent question is already waiting at home: what happens when their starter cannot get them through the middle innings?

Original editorial artwork for The Rays’ Next World Series Problem Is the Innings After Their Starter
Original editorial artwork; not a game photograph.

On Sunday, Oct. 25, the World Series is between games, but the Rays’ most urgent question is already waiting at home: what happens when their starter cannot get them through the middle innings?

Tampa Bay will take a 0-2 deficit into Monday’s Game 3 at Tropicana Field after Milwaukee turned a four-run first-inning hole into a 5-4 win Saturday. The Rays had the start they wanted from the offense and the pitcher they trusted most on the mound. They still lost. The hinge was the gap between those plans: Drew Rasmussen left before the fourth inning was over, and Tampa Bay’s relief corps had to cover the rest of a game against a lineup that kept making them work.

That is a different challenge from simply needing more hits. In Game 2, the Rays scored four times before Milwaukee had recorded three outs. Liam Hicks supplied a two-run homer; Chandler Simpson and Junior Caminero added run-scoring singles. But the lead did not give the Rays a shorter game. Instead, the Brewers chipped away, and Tampa Bay had to keep finding arms—and outs—to protect what remained. (mlb.com)

A fast start, then a long night

Rasmussen’s outing began to unravel not with one dramatic blow, but with a string of difficult plate appearances. Milwaukee’s first inning included four singles, and the Brewers pushed him to 29 pitches. Tampa Bay also made a costly defensive mistake: Jonathan Aranda dropped a foul pop-up that could have become the second out. Rasmussen returned for the fourth but did not finish it, leaving after 3⅔ innings with the Rays still ahead. (mlb.com)

That early exit matters because it changed the terms of the game. The Rays’ best version of the night would have paired the four-run cushion with length from Rasmussen, preserving their relievers for the highest-leverage moments. Instead, Tampa Bay had to piece together more than five innings. The Brewers’ official game story records the sequence that followed: Sal Frelick tied the game with a solo homer in the sixth against Ian Seymour, then rookie Cooper Pratt put Milwaukee ahead with a single in the seventh against Kevin Kelly. (mlb.com)

The distinction is important. This was not a bullpen asked to protect a one-run lead from the opening pitch. It was a bullpen entering a contest whose shape had already changed: the starter had been chased early, the Brewers had spent the first innings extending at-bats, and Tampa Bay’s margin was shrinking. The Rays could still have escaped with a win, but the workload and the leverage kept accumulating.

Milwaukee made every out cost something

The Brewers did not erase the deficit with one huge inning. They forced Tampa Bay to keep defending. Milwaukee’s game story notes that Rasmussen threw 89 pitches, and the Rays’ account says the Brewers fouled off 22 of them while swinging and missing only nine times. That kind of resistance can turn an apparently manageable lead into a roster-management problem: the starter needs more pitches to finish each inning, and the relievers arrive earlier than planned. (mlb.com)

Frelick’s home run was the most visible turning point, but it came after Tampa Bay had already been forced to use Seymour. Pratt’s go-ahead hit then came against Kelly. Those are not merely two separate scoring plays; they show Milwaukee moving the pressure from one pitcher to the next. Tampa Bay briefly had a chance to respond in the eighth, when it threatened with runners aboard, but Milwaukee escaped. Aaron Ashby then closed the ninth, striking out Yandy Díaz to finish the comeback. (mlb.com)

That is the part the Rays must study before Game 3. Their offense showed it could damage Milwaukee early. But a first-inning explosion is no guarantee the game will stay on Tampa Bay’s preferred schedule. When the starter exits early, each subsequent inning asks a fresh question of the bullpen—and gives the opponent another chance to find a favorable matchup or force another difficult decision.

Game 3 is a chance to change the conditions

The series now shifts to Tampa Bay, where Game 3 is scheduled for Monday, Oct. 26. That is useful context, not a solution by itself. The Rays need to avoid treating home field as a substitute for clean innings. They need their starter to work deeper, their defense to finish routine chances, and their bullpen to enter with a plan that does not depend on stopping a comeback after it has already gathered speed. (mlb.com)

The Rays’ own postgame reporting identifies the short start and the strain on the relief corps as a central concern. That does not mean one difficult outing defines their pitching staff, or that the next game must follow the same script. It does mean Milwaukee has shown it can make a lead feel temporary. The Brewers came back from four runs down in Game 2, just as their official recap describes, and won despite giving Tampa Bay a head start large enough to seem decisive. (mlb.com)

For Tampa Bay, the practical question is not simply whether it can score early again. It is whether that scoring can be supported by enough starter innings to keep the game from becoming a relay race. The Rays do not need to repeat the first inning; they need to make the next six or seven innings less complicated. A longer outing would preserve options. A cleaner defensive game would reduce avoidable pitches and outs. And if the bullpen is needed early, the Rays will need to make Milwaukee earn each transition rather than let the visitors dictate the sequence.

Two games do not decide a best-of-seven series, but they have sharpened the issue facing the Rays. Their offense can produce a lead. Now they need the pitching plan to make that lead last.

Sources

- MLB.com, Rays: “A 4-run lead with Ras on mound; what could go wrong?” mlb.com source - MLB.com: “Methodical Brewers erase 4-run deficit, pick apart Rays to seize 2-0 lead” mlb.com source - MLB.com Game Story, Rays at Brewers, Oct. 24, 2026 mlb.com source - MLB.com Postseason schedule mlb.com source - MLB.com, 2026 World Series schedule and FAQ mlb.com source

BRING THE KREWE INTO THE CONVERSATION

Worth a discussion? Pass it along.

Q
Q

Independent Tampa Bay coverage. Football first, with room for the whole sports conversation.

More reporting, analysis, and stories from The Plank Report.

Other Sports

Beyond the Bay: The Lightning’s Patch Program Puts Its Community Commitment on the Jersey

The Tampa Bay Lightning’s latest community announcement is built around something fans can see on the ice but may not think about after the game: a jersey patch. For the program’s third year, the team and its partners have named two Tampa Bay organizations that will receive support through “Patch with a Purpose,” extending the team’s work beyond the arena and into local services.

Read the story
Back to the front page
THE MORNING WATCH

Your Bay.
Your inbox.

The stories worth your time. The takes worth debating.
Join the launch list for our independent sports newsletter.