The Seven-Defenseman Bet: How Tampa Bay Managed Its Columbus Back-to-Back
By Friday evening, November 13, the Tampa Bay Lightning had finished their road trip and were looking ahead to a six-game homestand. The immediate question was not whether their offense could keep producing: after scoring eight goals in Buffalo on Wednesday, they won 3-1 in Columbus the next night. It was whether a compressed lineup and a relatively untested goaltender could hold up when the sched
By Friday evening, November 13, the Tampa Bay Lightning had finished their road trip and were looking ahead to a six-game homestand. The immediate question was not whether their offense could keep producing: after scoring eight goals in Buffalo on Wednesday, they won 3-1 in Columbus the next night. It was whether a compressed lineup and a relatively untested goaltender could hold up when the schedule offered little time to reset.
Tampa played the second half of the back-to-back without defenseman Erik Cernak and forward Anthony Cirelli, both listed as day-to-day after being injured against Buffalo. Yanni Gourde also sat out for maintenance. The Lightning dressed 11 forwards and seven defensemen, and Dennis Hildeby made 28 saves. In a game where Columbus pressed early, those decisions shaped the evening as much as the two late goals that settled it. (nhl.com)
A different kind of road win
Tampa’s win in Buffalo had been a high-scoring showcase. Columbus demanded a different response. The Blue Jackets had a rest advantage, while the Lightning were playing their second game in as many nights. Tampa opened the scoring at 2:57 of the first period when Brandon Hagel converted a rebound created by Charle-Edouard D’Astous’ shot from the high slot. Columbus tied it on Matthew Knies’ power-play goal at 12:20.
That first-period exchange left little margin for a tired team. Hildeby helped keep it there. His 28 saves gave Tampa a chance to find the game’s next opening without needing to match every Columbus push with a scoring chance of its own. Hagel later credited the goalie’s early work with helping the Lightning settle in. That is a player’s assessment, not proof that the saves alone changed the game; still, the sequence matters. Tampa got through a demanding opening stretch level, then scored twice in the third. (nhl.com)
The decisive break came at 1:06 of the third. Jake Guentzel took Hagel’s backhand pass in the left circle and scored to put Tampa ahead. Columbus defenseman Matthew Knies later said he had turned the puck over against some of Tampa’s best players. For the Lightning, the important detail was the quick conversion: the play gave them a lead early in the period, before Columbus could turn the final 20 minutes into a prolonged chase.
Hagel added an insurance goal at 7:41, scoring from a sharp angle below the right circle. He finished with two goals and an assist, while Guentzel had a goal and an assist and Nikita Kucherov recorded two assists. The point totals are the visible result; the larger story was that Tampa could make a low-scoring game turn on one costly turnover and then protect its advantage. (nhl.com)
The lineup choice behind the result
Using seven defensemen gave coach Jon Cooper another option on a night when the forward group was short. The official recap confirms the configuration, but does not specify how frequently Tampa rotated its defenders or exactly how the arrangement affected individual workloads. It would be a stretch, then, to declare the setup a blueprint from one game. What the result does show is that Tampa got through the back-to-back with a reduced forward group and without allowing Columbus to turn its second-period opportunities into a lead.
That matters because the absences were not all the same kind. Cernak and Cirelli had left the Buffalo game injured; Gourde’s absence was listed as maintenance. Cooper said Cernak and Cirelli were day-to-day. Those statuses offered no guarantee about their availability for the next game, and the team’s Saturday matchup against Detroit would be a new test, not simply an extension of the Columbus result. The practical question for Tampa was whether it could return to a more conventional lineup, or whether another adjustment would be needed. (nhl.com)
The goaltending decision also merits attention, but with the same caution. Tampa’s pregame notes identified Andrei Vasilevskiy and Hildeby as its goaltending options. Hildeby, who had not started against Columbus as a Lightning player, made 28 saves in the win. That performance is concrete evidence of his contribution on Thursday; it does not establish a new pecking order or predict who will start next. In a stretch with another game approaching Saturday, though, a reliable outing from the backup gives the coaching staff a useful result to weigh as it manages the schedule. (nhl.com)
A fresh test at home
There is also a useful contrast in the two road wins. Tampa scored eight times in Buffalo and three times in Columbus, but the latter game required patience and a save behind the defense. The Columbus recap put the Lightning at 6-1-2 over their previous nine games. That run speaks to results, not a guarantee that every lineup configuration will work. The Blue Jackets, meanwhile, had lost three straight and scored five goals across their previous four games, according to the same report. Tampa’s defensive work came against an offense having trouble finishing, a relevant limitation when considering what the performance proves. (nhl.com)
The next scheduled game was at home against Detroit on Saturday, November 14, beginning a six-game homestand. That setting changes the immediate question from surviving a road back-to-back to managing the roster across a longer run of home dates. The Lightning’s schedule announcement identifies the homestand as running from November 14 through November 27. It creates room to recover between games, but also puts the team’s depth decisions under a different kind of scrutiny: which players are available, and how quickly can Tampa restore its usual balance? (nhl.com)
The MLB postseason is over: Milwaukee defeated Tampa Bay in five games to win the 2026 World Series, according to MLB.com’s final results. With no active playoff series to preview, Tampa’s hockey roster question is the timely local story: the Columbus win showed that a seven-defenseman setup and a strong night from Hildeby could carry the Lightning through one difficult spot. The next evidence will come not from repeating that victory, but from seeing how the roster looks when the schedule turns homeward. (mlb.com)
Sources
- nhl.com source - nhl.com source - nhl.com source - nhl.com source - mlb.com source
Worth a discussion? Pass it along.
Keep reading
Browse the story archive ↗More reporting, analysis, and stories from The Plank Report.
Beyond the Bay: The Lightning’s Patch Program Puts Its Community Commitment on the Jersey
The Tampa Bay Lightning’s latest community announcement is built around something fans can see on the ice but may not think about after the game: a jersey patch. For the program’s third year, the team and its partners have named two Tampa Bay organizations that will receive support through “Patch with a Purpose,” extending the team’s work beyond the arena and into local services.
Read the storyBeyond the Bay: Tampa Bay’s Cirelli Matchup Shows How the Lightning Can Win Without Brandon Hagel
Tampa Bay’s 3-1 victory over Edmonton on Thursday offered more than a stopping point for Connor McDavid’s season-opening scoring streak. It showed how the Lightning can reorganize their forward lines around a difficult assignment—and still get decisive offense from elsewhere.
Read the storyBeyond the Bay: With Hagel Out, Tampa Bay’s Depth Faces Its Biggest Test Yet
Brandon Hagel’s absence changes the shape of Tampa Bay’s challenge against Edmonton. It is not just a goal scorer missing from the lineup: the Lightning must reassign a forward who had been tied for the team lead in goals while facing an Oilers club arriving with a six-game winning streak and an elite power play.
Read the story